• Home
  • Our Team
    • About Chris Thornton
    • About the Psychologists
    • Consulting to The Redleaf Practice >
      • A/Prof Sloane Madden
      • Dr Sheeny Shanker-Butler
  • Join Our Team
  • Eating Disorders
    • Anorexia Nervosa
    • Bulimia Nervosa
    • Binge Eating Disorder
    • Treatment >
      • Family Based Treatment
      • Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
    • Resources >
      • Resources for Parents/Carers
      • Resources for Clients
      • Client Forms
  • Psychology FAQs
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  Welcome to The Redleaf Practice
(02) 9487 7799

Families and Eating Disorders

5/6/2011

2 Comments

 
Thanks to Melinda Hutchings I read a blog by the director of the Eating Disorder Resource Centre, Dr. Judith Brisman.  Her blog discusses the possible role of family functioning in the development of eating disorders.  You can read her blog here.

She begins to allude to the concept of an "anorexicogenic family" where features of the family, particularly "enmeshment" and "overcontrol" were thought to be related to the development of an eating disorder.   As Dr. Brisman points out, the studies that described this were methodologically flawed and therefore inconclusive at best, and damaging to families at worst.  The concept seems similar to the "schizophrenogenic" family pattern that used to be thought to "cause" schizophrenia.  That is of course until we discovered that schizophrenia is a biological illness.  Dr. Brisman points to some studies indicating a biological basis to anorexia, but I will talk about those in a later post.

Dr. Brisman is correct when she asserts that ALL families, not just those with children with eating disorders, present with a combination of psychopathology, and strength and resiliency.  However, lets take those 1000 families that she wants to see in a research trial and then lets give their child a potentially chronic and life threatening disease.  We could choose an illness like leukaemia.  These families, I would boldly predict would demonstrate features like closeness and pulling together ("enmeshment") and maybe also try to control their distress in front of their child ("emotional overcontrol") and be worried about their child's activities and behaviour ("behavioural overcontrol").  I dare say these parents would demonstrate emotions and behaviour in line with an adjustment disorder, worry  and anxiety ("psychopathology").  

If we also treated these families as if they somehow caused the leukaemia (even if we didn't quite know how) and isolated them from the process of treatment, I suspect the parents behaviour may appear to be even more "pathological".  

My point is that we as clinicians (and as society) have a negative bias when it comes to mental health and we look for pathology where we would not in a medical condition.

Now, eating disorders are not quite like leukaemia are they.  Patients with leukaemia do not want their illness as someone with anorexia may appear to.  They will not fight against parents to help them.  They will not act to undermine treatment.  Thus, the parents of a child with an eating disorder are also faced with the egosyntonicity of the illness.  This feature of the eating disorders increases the difficulties parents face.  The frustration of wanting to help someone who actively resists help can be overwhelming for clinicians, let alone parents.  I suspect this part of the battle increases what we may see as "pathology" in the family.

So, Dr. Brisman's study not only needs to take 1000 families, but also needs to take into account the effects of having a child with a life threatening illness, the stigma of mental health, difficult access to treatment, and a child who resists treatment.  Given these conditions I would love to study the family that does not react in a way that could be considered as 'pathological'.   I strongly suspect that the family features that are seen to cause eating disorders are caused by a natural reaction to the trauma of  having a child with an eating disorder.  The research backs this hypothesis up.

Families are an important resource for treatment, particularly in children and adolescents.  The outcome of  patients treated with Maudsley Family Based Therapy is a testament to this.  We are currently looking at ways to increase support for parents whose children are suffering from the eating disorders to decrease there feelings of guilt and blame, and to increase their effectiveness into helping their children overcome these insidious diseases.


If you would like to comment on this feel free to do so on our Facebook page.
2 Comments
Becky Henry link
9/6/2011 10:20:03 am

Thank you seems so abundantly inadequate here Chris. I have been waiting millions of moments to hear a treatment provider say these words. I didn't know if I would live to see the day. This is my favorite part of your post: "...the effects of having a child with a life threatening illness, the stigma of mental health, difficult access to treatment, and a child who resists treatment. Given these conditions I would love to study the family that does not react in a way that could be considered as 'pathological'. I strongly suspect that the family features that are seen to cause eating disorders are caused by a natural reaction to the trauma of having a child with an eating disorder."

This is what parents need to hear.

I have now devoted my life to helping families living with eds to reclaim their joy, get their own oxygen masks on and bringing them tools and resources for coping.

Thank you for being the voice all parents need to hear round the world.

Dr. Brisman speaks of research...well, instead of finding something/someone to blame for eating disorders, I am doing something.

As I need to be connecting with parents anyhow to let them know about my recently published, award winning book for families, I am setting up a research fund with the AED to have every one of the 70 million families around the world contribute $1 each to eating disorders research. Then we can find some more answers that are backed up by science.

Becky Henry

Reply
Jane Cawley link
17/6/2011 01:21:49 am

Dr. Brisman seems to have overlooked a study similar to the one she calls for. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2009 Aug;48(8):791-9.
Childhood risk factors for lifetime anorexia nervosa by age 30 years in a national birth cohort.
Nicholls DE, Viner RM.

OBJECTIVE:

To examine whether previously identified childhood risk factors for anorexia nervosa (AN) predict self-reported lifetime AN by age 30 years in a prospective birth cohort.
METHOD:

Using data from the 1970 British Cohort Study, at birth, 5, 10, and 30 years, we examined associations between suggested childhood risk factors and self-reported lifetime AN at 30 years, adjusted for sex and socioeconomic status.
RESULTS:

Anorexia nervosa was independently predicted by female sex (odds ratio [OR] 22.1), infant feeding problems (OR 2.6), maternal depressive symptoms (OR 1.8), and a history of undereating (OR 2.7). High self-esteem (OR 0.3) and higher maternal body mass index (OR 0.91) were protective.
CONCLUSIONS:

Of 22 suggested risk factors for AN, only four risk and two protective factors were confirmed in this prospective cohort study. We did not identify a role for perinatal factors, parenting, childhood body mass index, childhood emotional or sleep problems, academic ability, or exercise.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Chris Thornton is a Clinical Psychologist and the Clinical Director of The Redleaf Practice, a specialist outpatient clinic for the treatment of eating disorders.  He is interested in bringing elements of positive psychology, Cognitive Behavioural Therapy and Acceptance and Mindfulness approaches to the treatment of eating disorders.   

    Picture

    Archives

    April 2019
    June 2018
    May 2018
    November 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    May 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All
    Act
    Adolescent
    Anorexia
    Anorexia Nervosa
    Anosognisia
    Bed Shortage
    Better Access
    Bulimia
    CBT Treatment Of Anorexia Adults. SWAN
    Clinician Alliance
    Depression
    Eating Disorders
    Evidence Based Treatment
    Families
    Ipt
    Maudsley Family Based Therapy
    Mfbt
    Mfbt Anorexia Adolescent Maudsley
    Mindfulness
    Obesity
    Recovery
    Social Media
    Sscm
    The Redleaf Practice
    Treatment
    Weight Loss

    RSS Feed

    The Redleaf Practice

    Promote Your Page Too
Chris Thornton & Associates. The Redleaf Practice. 
Photo used under Creative Commons from Pai Shih